Tribute to Council“Schools are the microcosm of multiculturism”, Mrs. Simmonds said, while Principal of Xavier College, John Finn summed up the basic priorities for interfaith understanding and dialogue when he said “we cannot live with other people unless we know who they are, where they come from and what they believe”. Victorian Supreme Court Judge, Justice Stephen Charles, who chaired the panel session concluded that “there is hope for a society which encourages people of one persuasion to live in harmony and understanding with another”. He paid tribute to the Council of Christians and Jews the work of which, he said, was today more important than ever.
Rabbi Raymond AppleThe Sermon on the Mount in the Gospel of Matthew spells out Jesus’ concept of prayer. He tells his followers not to show off when praying or to “go babbling on like the heathen” (Matthew 6:2-8). He directs them to pray in this fashion:
It is related that Jesus was praying in a certain place and when he ceased, one of his disciples said: “Lord, teach us to pray, as John taught his disciples” (Luke 11:1). The devout Jew of the time believed in Kavvanah, deep concentration on prayer. The Hassidim (early pietists), spent as much as an hour in meditation before they prayed. Maybe it was at such a moment, when Jesus was deeply immersed in pre-devotional contemplation, that his disciples spoke to him. The Talmud offers interesting parallels. While not all strictly contemporary, they illustrate this tradition. For example, Rabbi Eliezer, on concluding the statutory prayers, used to say:
Rabbi Alexandri used to say: “Sovereign of the Universe, it is well known to You that our will is to perform Your will. What prevents us? The evil impulse, which causes a ferment in our heart and the subjection to foreign powers. May it be your will to save us from their hand so that we may again perform the statutes of Your will with a perfect heart.” A favourite saying of the rabbis of Yavneh was: “I am God’s creature; my fellow man is God’s creature. My work is in the town, and his work is in the country. I rise early for my work, and he rises early for his. Will you say, ’I do much and he does little’? We have learned that it matters not if one does much or little, provided he directs his heart to his Teacher in heaven” (Ber. 16b). Echo of the KaddishJesus’ prayer combines many of the features of prayers which were common use in Pharisee circles. It is not doctrinal nor does it claim that the Messiah has arrived in the person of Jesus. The first part of the text (“Hallowed be Your Name”) is a prayer for the coming of the Kingdom of God. This echoes the Kaddish, which begins with the paragraph:
The invocation “Our Father”, in Hebrew Avinu, or simply Abba, as in Luke, is common as a form of address to God in the Jewish liturgy. The full formula, “Our Father in heaven”, goes back to the Hassidim.Calling God “Our Father’ reflects the statutory benedictions recited three times a day in the Amidah, e.g.: “Cause us to return, O our Father, to Your law; draw us near, O our King, to Your service.” Or “Forgive us, our Father, for we have sinned; pardon us, our King, for we have transgressed.” Messianic themeThe Jewish parallels to the Lord’s Prayer indicate that Jesus was expressing in Luke and Matthew the yearning of his generation for the coming of the Messiah. There is a striking parallel in a first century prayer in the name of Rabbi Eliezer: “Do Your will in heaven above and give tranquillity of spirit to those that fear You on earth, and do what is good in Your eyes. Blessed are You, who hearkens to prayer”. Some scholars find a messianic theme in the phrase: “Give us today our daily (apportioned) bread”. Reference is made by such scholars to Rabbi Eliezer of Modin who said: “He who created the day, created also its provision; so he, who, while having sufficient food for the day says, ’What shall I eat tomorrow?’, belongs to the men of little faith, such as were the Israelites at the giving of the manna” (Mekhilta Beshallach II; Sotah 48b). This is parallel to what Jesus says later on in a kind of extended commentary on the Lord’s Prayer. He says: “Do not be anxious …. what you shall eat. Take no thought for your life … O you of little faith, seek first the Kingdom of God.” Talmud parallelElsewhere the Talmud asks: “For whom is sin pardoned? For him who forgives
injury”. This is parallel with what Jesus says in Mark 11:25: “When you
stand praying, if you have a grievance against anyone, forgive him, so that your
Father in heaven may forgive you the wrongs you have done”. We come now to the
final phrase: “Do not bring us to the test, but save us from evil” some
versions, “from the evil one”). Again there is a parallel in the Talmud: “Never
should a man subject himself to temptations as David did, saying, ’Examine me,
O Lord, and prove me’ (Psalm 26:2).” According to James 1:15, sin is the
work of Satan. This accounts for the reading, “But deliver us from the evil
one”. The theme of this verse is found with variations in many Hassidic
prayers; however, the early Pharisees gradually softened the expression “the
evil one” into “the evil inclination” (yetzer ha-ra). Other
formulations have ”evil accidents” and “evil companionship”. The idea of
Satan as an independent being never figured very strongly in Jewish thought; and
it is natural, therefore, for Jesus to soften it into “things evil”. The
passage added in some versions, “For Yours is the kingdom, the power and the
glory for ever and ever” has its source in I Chronicles 29:11. The almost
identical words are used in the synagogue, before the Scroll of the Torah is
opened for public reading; it is we not certain how old this ritual is, but it
is significant that these words, which may not have been in the original Lord’s
Prayer, are used for the liturgical chant with which the prayer was concluded in
church worship.
Last year the ICJS assembled a remarkable group of scholars in Baltimore to launch an inquiry into the complex interplay of Choral Arts and Christian theology -- particularly the enduring legacy of Christian anti-Judaism. Participants included: Margot Fassler (Director of Sacred Music, Yale Divinity School); Richard Freedman (Professor of Music, Haverford College); Michael Marrisen (Music Department Chair, Swarthmore College); Amy-Jill Levine (Professor of New Testament Studies, Vanderbilt Divinity School); Sanford Sylvan (opera singer); Tom Hall (Director of the Baltimore Choral Arts Society); Rosann Catalano (ICJS Roman Catholic scholar); Charles Arian (ICJS Jewish scholar); John Roberts (Associate ICJS scholar); and Christopher M. Leighton (ICJS Executive Director). Preliminary goals of the new project were briefly outlined: To demonstrate how anti-Judaism has found a home in choral music; to convince conductors, performers, and audiences that the problem of anti-Judaism in music exists and needs to be taken seriously; and to suggest ways of educating conductors, performers, and audiences so that anti-Judaism in choral works can be recognized and understood.
The first meeting on attempted to identify the issues and challenges facing the project and to suggest ways in which to frame these issues and challenges in order to generate future educational responses. During the one-day conference, the discussion ranged across many topics, including: the importance of teaming musicologists with biblical scholars to help make the transition between religious text and art; fostering understanding of the anti-Judaic elements in the work without destroying the appreciation of the music; and addressing the problems associated with revising or editing the music to remove the objectionable portions. The discussion attempted to identify clearly the broadest possible audience for the project and at the same time to address the considerable concerns of performers and scholars in the field. As the project moves forward with the support of the Marco Goodman Trust in San Francisco, the ICJS will: Identify four or five themes that need to be taught and choose music to teach these themes (or identify key pieces of music that illustrate anti-Judaism); Increase theological understanding as a crucial component to learning; Present issues in historical segments (e.g., the medieval period, the Renaissance, etc.) that help make the theological concepts easier to understand in context; Identify and bring together a distinguished group of scholars from music and theology for a symposium out of which a volume of essays can be generated along with other resources.
We view with deep concern various expressions of animosity towards Jews in our countries. Jewish dialogue partners describe an increase in antisemitism, which has taken many forms: graffiti on synagogues and Jewish cemeteries, verbal abuse, telephone threats, and even physical violence. Reports such as the study of the European Monitoring Centre on Racism and Xenophobia ("Manifestations of Antisemitism in the EU 2002–2003") confirm this increase of antisemitism and call for measures to combat it: "Europe’s political leaders must make it very clear that they do not accept antisemitism and racism by taking a strong leadership position on the issue." (EUMC 31-3-04). We expect an equally strong attitude from church leaders and from all church members, since from a theological point of view, "antisemitism is sin against God and humanity" (First Assembly of the World Council of Churches, Amsterdam, 1948, "The Christian Approach to the Jews"). Likewise the "Charta Oecumenica – Guidelines for the Growing Cooperation among the Churches in Europe" (Conference of European Churches and Council of European Bishops’ Conferences) states: "We commit ourselves: to oppose all forms of antisemitism and anti-Judaism in the church and in society; to seek and intensify dialogue with our Jewish sisters and brothers at all levels." As Lutherans we bear a special responsibility in light of anti-Jewish elements in the Lutheran tradition. This has been an issue at LEKKJ Conferences for years, indeed decades. For example, the LEKKJ Declaration of Driebergen, The Netherlands (1990) states: "We strongly urge that, within the Lutheran Churches, the anti-Jewish attacks in Luther’s later words and their disastrous consequences be worked on as has been done in the Stockholm statement of 1983. We also urge that the fundamental patterns of Lutheran theology and teaching . . . be reconsidered in view of their effects on the relationship between Christians and Jews." We regret that these commitments are not yet shared by all church members. This challenge is still an acute problem. Today we see antisemitism showing itself in the form of anti-Zionism. As churches we have close and lasting ties with the Jewish people and with the state of Israel. Our faith also gives us an inherent relationship with Palestinian Christians. Despite efforts to achieve a balanced position, we often see an unbalance favouring the Palestinian point of view within our churches. In the public debate about these issues, we often note antisemitic allusions, as expressed, for example, in the intolerable equation of the Israeli government’s present policies with the National Socialist policy of annihilation. To criticise the policies of the State of Israel is not per se antisemitic. But it becomes so when the very existence of the State of Israel is called into question. In public discussions, anti-Jewish clichés such as "retribution" and "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth" occur repeatedly. We must state emphatically that political disagreements do not justify attacks on Jews. We further assert: The state of Israel has the right and the obligation to protect itself and its citizens from terror. This statement was adopted by the European Lutheran Commission on the Church and the Jewish People (LEKKJ), in which 25 Lutheran church bodies in Europe are represented, at its annual meeting in Cluj-Klausenberg, Romania earlier this year. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||